Keyworth Proposal: The Details

COgPj9tWIAAHQAR.jpg large

This morning, DCFC ownership released the main points of their plan regarding the impending move of the club to Keyworth Stadium in Hamtramck. Among the highlights:

What improvements are being proposed to Keyworth?
Detroit City FC proposes to create an extraordinary stadium atmosphere through the following improvements: Make urgent structural improvements to the west (press box side) grandstand and repair all the wooden bleachers to allow for complete access throughout; update and rehabilitate the locker rooms and public restrooms under the west grandstand; repair concrete in the east grandstand to create a traditional standing supporters terrace; repair the field lighting at the stadium to DCFC’s standards, and make immediate grooming of the field turf at the stadium, with intentions to install a grass field in the near future.

When the club began play at Cass Tech in 2012, the bulk of the work put into the stadium went into rehabilitating the field, which was in pretty rough shape at the time. Keyworth is much more of a fixer-upper, as it will require serious renovations to the structure itself, including extensive concrete work. It remains to be seen which aspects of construction will be completed in time for next season, and which will be ongoing throughout the year and into 2017. Having to play on field turf for a year would definitely be a bit of a bummer.

What will capacity be at the rehabbed Keyworth?
The initial proposed rehabilitation work completed before the start of the 2016 season would get capacity up to 6,000, with room to grow with future improvements.
With crowds this season pushing the 4000 mark, 6000 provides room for growth without putting pressure on supporters to fill up a massive stadium right off the bat. An average attendance of somewhere between 4000 and 5000 for next year would be a good starting point.
At a date in the near future, DCFC would announce the terms of this opportunity and invite supporters to participate at tiered levels in a community-sourced “revenue share loan,” which would be repaid, with interest, according to the revenues earned by DCFC. This approach would allow the club’s supporters to share in some of the risk and some of the upside of the club’s operations. 
 
To be clear, this would not be an equity offering of ownership in the team, rather this would be an opportunity for individuals and organizations to contribute to the rehabilitation effort, help grow DCFC, and come away with interest on a loan they make to the club.
This point may have been lost in the shuffle, but in the near future, supporters will be able to directly contribute money to the club. This should not be construed as “supporter ownership,” which some clubs falsely advertise, but “supporter investment.” Ventures such as these are relatively new in American sports, and it will be interesting to see the results of City’s plan of action.
How does the stadium fit in to Detroit City FC’s future?
Keyworth would be the next step in the growth of Detroit City FC. Detroit City FC has been actively working to move up to a higher professional league. When that move takes place, Keyworth would be a perfect initial home that could allow us to be financially viable at the professional level. 
 
When will Detroit City FC play in Detroit again?
Our long-term goal is to have a soccer-specific stadium of our own in the city of Detroit. We are continuously having conversations to this end, but it will take years to line up the investments, land, and complete construction before we’ll be able to host a game at a stadium in the city.

Two big takeaways here:

(1) Ownership is looking to move the club up to a professional level.

(2) Keyworth is likely a stepping stone on the way to a new permanent home.

Although it wasn’t mentioned in the press release, the field size of Keyworth would allow the club to host Open Cup matches, which was an impossibility at Cass. Additionally, stadium availability would presumably allow April preseason matches, which were held in Berkley the past two years, to be held at home.

Last year I speculated that renting rather than purchasing Keyworth could be a short-term solution to allow the club to continue growing while maintaining flexibility – sort of like living with a roomate while saving money for your own place. It appears that I was correct. City’s owners don’t seem to be content to settle on Keyworth as a long-term venue; their ultimate plan is to construct a soccer stadium in the heart of Detroit. Whether or not that becomes a reality may hinge on how successful the upcoming move goes, as well as the supporter investment venture.

end

Number Crunchin’: 2015 Attendance

With another season in the books, it’s time to take a closer look at this year’s attendance numbers.

Links to previous editions2013  2014

Sources are as follows:

Detroit City FC attendance numbers are announced at games and posted to the club’s official Twitter account.

NASL numbers: Soccer Stadium Digest

USL-Pro numbers: Wiki page/uslsoccer.com

PDL numbers: kenn.com

break

Previous average home attendance numbers (Competitive Matches):

2012: 1295  CLICK HERE for game-by-game table

2013: 1715  CLICK HERE for game-by-game table

2014: 2857  CLICK HERE for game-by-game table

And now for this year:

2015att

break

Notes:

  • The 2014 attendance record of 3398 (7/11 vs. Fort Pitt) was topped 5 times this year, and was actually lower than the regular season average of 3528.
  • City drew over 3000 for every single league match in 2015.
  • Combined attendance at this year’s three friendlies isn’t far from matching 2012’s TOTAL season attendance (8582 to 9948).
  • Since the beginning, the club’s yearly attendance averages have nearly tripled (1295 in 2012 vs. 3528 in 2015).
  • Over the course of four years and 35 home games (competitive + friendlies), City has drawn a total of 78,627 fans.

A Couple Handy Graphs:

gamegraph

yeargraph

How do we measure up?

If Detroit City FC was added to the following leagues, their 2015 regular season average attendance of 3528 would put them:

1st (out of 66) in the PDL

9th (out of 25) in USL Pro

11th (out of 12) in NASL

Additionally, when it comes to the NPSL, Chattanooga had massive crowds for their playoff matches (including over 18,000 for the League Final), but City actually had a higher regular season average attendance (3528 to 3084).

What does it all mean?

At the final league match of 2014 against Fort Pitt, around 400 people were turned away at the gate. I took this as evidence that we had effectively outgrown Cass Tech and that the club stood to lose tens of thousands of dollars in 2015 in lost ticket sales from refusing people admission.

As it turns out, we still had a little room to grow. Ownership took steps to push capacity up by a few hundred with a couple added sitting and standing areas, and I don’t believe anyone was turned away until the final stretch of Lansing-Michigan-Erie.

That being said, I do think that we’ve NOW officially outgrown Cass. There just isn’t any more space, and it doesn’t make sense to dump more money than necessary into a venue at which you don’t have a long-term future.

While all signs continue to point to Keyworth Stadium  as City’s probable next home, the timetable remains unclear. The initial estimate for the cost of renovations has slowly crept up from $1 million to $3 million to the most recent figure of $5 million. Because of this, it appears that the club will most likely remain at Cass in 2016, with the final word probably coming sometime in September or October.

One more year of the status quo wouldn’t be the end of the world, but for the club to continue growing, it needs a bigger home in 2017. Before there can be serious discussions about City moving up to a higher division, I think average attendance needs to grow to at least 5000-5500, which would put the club at or near the middle of the NASL.

Going by current growth rates, if a move to Keyworth happens, I think we could reach those numbers by the second or third year. I’ve held back on making this prediction for a couple years, but with all I’ve seen and heard over the past 18 months, I’m ready to pull the trigger and say that I think City will be in the NASL or an equivalent league by the end of the decade.

end

Who Will Get the Armband?

Photo by Michael Kitchen
Photo by Michael Kitchen

The Favorite: Barring any surprises or injuries, City’s next captain will be Dave Edwardson. He was the first choice to wear the armband this year whenever Josh Rogers wasn’t in the lineup, and his combination of experience and workrate in midfield make him the obvious pick.

The Contenders: After Edwardson, the most logical candidate would be Latif Alashe, one of the few players who’s been on the roster since 2012. He took the role of captain in the second half of the regular season finale and will likely see more of that duty next year whenever Edwardson is out.

Rounding out the top three, Seb Harris saw more of the field this season than in 2014 and really grew into a key player on the back line. With Rogers’ departure, he will have to assume a greater degree of leadership over the defense, regardless of his title.

The Wildcard: As a fan favorite, possibly THE fan favorite, Alex Isaevski would make for an interesting choice. He’s probably a bit young at this point, but he could be a serious contender the next time the captaincy is vacant.

Other Candidates: Zach Schewee, Zach Myers, Wade Allan, Danny Dragoi

end

CityBits ’15: Stars (I)

Saturday, July 11th, 2015 – Detroit City FC 3, Michigan Stars 1

Photo by Dion Degennaro
Photo by Dion Degennaro

Baby, Please Don’t Go We saw flashes of it last year (see what I did there?), but in his second season Will Mellors-Blair has become the most dangerous attacking player in City’s history. His most obvious asset, his speed, is a nightmare for even the quickest defenders, but his ball control, dribbling, and finishing are what make him such a dynamic threat. He’s your 2015 Black Arrow Award winner; even though the voting has yet to take place, he could sit out every remaining game this season and nobody else would even come close.

The problem is, he very well may have just played his final game of the season. Word is that UM head coach Chaka Daley wants his players to rest and recuperate right around this time of year so that they come back to preseason training healthy and fresh. This is completely reasonable and understandable, and I’m sure most college coaches would agree with his line of thinking.

I’m not sure what say WMB has in the matter, but if he has future professional aspirations, I would argue that playing as the lead striker for a team looking to compete for an NPSL championship is a fantastic opportunity to increase his profile and gain exposure. It’s a tough situation, but hopefully it can be resolved with as little difficulty as possible.

Contingency Plans If he does have to shut it down, things get awfully dicey for City. What appeared to be a strength at the beginning of the season (attacking depth) has become an area of concern, mainly due to injuries. Zach Myers has been absent for most of the year, and in the couple games he got into, he clearly wasn’t healthy. Javi Ramirez should be getting closer to a return from his knee surgery, but it would be unfair to expect him to come in and immediately return to the level he showed before he got hurt.

In the event of a WMB departure (as well as James Murphy, another UM forward), City’s strikers are as follows: Tyler Channell, Charlie MacInnes, Wade Allan. That’s just not enough depth to make a title run, and if you take away WMB’s dynamism, City go from favorites to win the Midwest tournament to just about even with whichever other three teams make the playoff. If Jeff Adkins could be pried away from the Bucks it would help, but as it stands now it appears Ben Pirmann may soon have to get creative with his lineups.

New Cardinals The aforementioned Channell has provided strong hold-up play and chipped in a couple goals this season, and his college teammate Alexandre Bouillennec has noticeably improved over his past several games in goal, but among this year’s SVSU newcomers, the one that has stood out the most has been Troy Watson.

And by stand out, I refer to the quality of his play, not how noticeable he is on the field, because most of the time you hardly realize he’s out there. If you watch closely however, you can see what a big impact he has on games – primarily in breaking up attacks and closing down the ball to slow or derail opposing runs.

watson

The gif above shows a typical moment from him – chasing down his man after a nice 1-2, easing him off the ball, eluding a would-be tackler, and playing a simple pass out to the flank.

His play helps shield the back line and I think it’s one of the main reasons why team defending has improved so much from where it was last year and early on in this season.

Fashion Police I’m not gonna beat the proverbial dead horse about Stars coach Mark Christensen’s criminal past. You can read all about it here if you so desire. What I WILL do is talk about his most recent offense, the crime against fashion he committed on Saturday:

CJrD5bUUsAEKCFG.png large

Yes that is a t-shirt under a suit coat, and yes that is a gold chain.

For comparison:

Degennaro
Degennaro

The day Caesar wears a t-shirt with a sport coat is the day he’s given up on life for good.

Attendance 3884 is the new home record. Every time the mark is broken, I think: “So that’s what Cass’ real capacity is. No way we can fit any more.” At this point, though, we might as well go for 4000. I’m sure there’s enough standing room to make it happen. Fire marshal shmire shmarshal.

Standings & Playoff Picture With Sunday’s results, City has officially clinched a spot in the Midwest tournament. They still have work to do if they want to play said tournament at Cass, though. The current table:

mwlw15

Madison is also in, and it’s down to Buffalo, Cleveland, and Indy Fire for the final two spots.

Your Moment of Zen As a footnote, I have to mention The Lansing United’s zero-point weekend, capped off by a 5-0 drubbing at the hands of AFC Cleveland. After going unbeaten in its first 7, TLU has now lost 4 in a row by a combined score of 9-0 and has been eliminated from playoff contention. The hip thing seems to be posting a picture/gif/video that metaphorically represents this epic collapse, so I thought I’d join in the fun.

smiley

end

This Perfect Day

Saturday, June 20th, 2015 – Detroit City FC 3, Cincinnati 1

11541002_10152818937310826_2502806713962935412_n
Photo by Michael Kitchen

Whether you’re old or young, male or female, sinner or saint, the reality of the modern human experience is that much of your life will consist of drudgery. Sitting in traffic, waiting in lines, spending the bulk of your day at a job that, if you’re lucky, doesn’t suck too hard – these things are typical to most of our lives. Put it all together and things can get a bit frustrating. Throw a little adversity and a couple personal troubles on top and it can feel overwhelming.

What makes life livable are the golden moments that occur in the midst of this daily grind. They may be found in the ecstasy of love and companionship, the thrill of new sights and experiences, or simply by losing yourself in a hobby or activity for which you have true passion. One moment of bliss can make all the difficulties of the previous weeks or months seem like distant memories.

One of the main reasons we watch sports is that, unless your team is utter trash, they can provide us with those precious moments of spontaneous joy. That’s why we subject ourselves to, for instance, driving through hours of highway construction and absurdly low speed limits with barely a sight to see. We know that at the end of the journey there’s a chance, however small, that we might see something special and feel THAT feeling once again.

Photo by Dion Degennaro
Photo by Dion Degennaro

break

Random Thoughts

The Game As I predicted and hoped for at the beginning of the season, the team appears to be coming together after a couple of early-season hiccups. They were clearly the better team on Saturday as well as last week at Minnesota Utd. Reserves, and getting 4 points out of two road games which each featured highly questionable red cards is a big accomplishment.

City wasn’t able to generate much in the first half, but absolutely dominated the last 30 minutes of the game, especially after going down a man. The bulk of their chances and pressure were generated from Will Mellors-Blair and Alex Isaevski combining down the left wing. The team ended up scoring 3, but with a hit post and a couple other near misses, it easily could’ve been 4 or 5.

The Refs Speaking of the red cards, I don’t really know what to say that hasn’t already been said dozens of times. We’ve grown accustomed to ridiculous refereeing decisions over the years, and until we move up to a higher league, it’s unrealistic to expect things to change. That being said, as a league that’s one step below the professional level, things like this are unacceptable:

CHe4VNwUMAAkmB0.jpg large

If someone is too young to be an official at a high school match, he should not be part of a crew that’s calling a match between teams of grown men.

PirmannWear™ I’ve been slacking off in this department lately, so here’s a double dose: (both photos by Michael Kitchen)

Daydreaming Caesar Photo by Michael Kitchen
Daydreaming Caesar
Reflective Caesar
Reflective Caesar

False Alarm Yes the Cincinnati Fire Department really showed up: four trucks in total, in response to the dozen or so smokesticks set off simultaneously after Danny Dragoi’s go-ahead goal.

...because of this.
Cause…
...effect
…effect

“That time the fire department showed up because of our smoke,” will now go down in City lore and be remembered by everyone who witnessed it.

Up Next This coming weekend is crucial – first up is another road trip to a weak team that should be beaten (Fort Pitt), and then there’s the rematch against Lansing at home. A win on Friday and any result on Sunday would put City in very good position to secure a playoff spot.

end