Totals through end of 2019 season
Includes goals in all official competitions (NPSL Regular Season, NPSL Playoffs, NPSL Members Cup, US Open Cup)
1. Shawn Lawson – 36
2. Cyrus Saydee – 18
3. Will Mellors-Blair – 15
T-4.
Zach Myers – 12
Max Todd – 12
T-6.
Jeff Adkins – 10
Seb Harris – 10
8. Knox Cameron – 9
T-9.
Danny Deakin – 7
Roddy Green – 7
Josh Rogers – 7
Kevin Taylor – 7
T-13.
Dave Edwardson – 6
Tyrone Mondi – 6
T-15.
Adam Bedell – 5
Kyle Bethel – 5
Yazeed Matthews – 5
Brogan Shrimpton – 5
T-19.
Latif Alashe – 4
Trevor Amann – 4
Stephen Carroll – 4
Tommy Catalano – 4
T-23.
Tyler Arnone – 3
Javi Bautista – 3
Tyler Channell – 3
Bakie Goodman – 3
Alec Lasinski – 3
Keith Lough – 3
Rafa Mentzingen – 3
Elijah Rice – 3
Stefan St. Louis – 3
T-32.
Santiago Agudelo – 2
Tommy Buono – 2
Grant Chong – 2
Danny Dragoi – 2
David Dwaihy – 2
Moussa Gueye – 2
Miche’le Lipari – 2
Tom Oatley – 2
Austin Oldham – 2
Fabio Pereira – 2
Ryan Peterson – 2
Locky Savage – 2
Zach Schewee – 2
Omar Sinclair – 2
Tyler Stephens – 2
Jakub Svehlik – 2
Jordan Tyler – 2
T.J. Van Slooten – 2
Matt Ybarra – 2
T-51.
Ali Al-Gashamy – 1
Jonathan Barnes – 1
Marcelo Borges – 1
Rich Bryan – 1
Brad Centala – 1
Jalen Crisler – 1
Louis Dargent – 1
Abdoulaye Diop – 1
Jon Evans – 1
Spencer Glass – 1
Zeke Harris – 1
Craig Hearn – 1
Owain Hoskins – 1
Alex Isaevski – 1
Michael Lamb – 1
Sean Magee – 1
Colin McAtee – 1
Tyler Moorman – 1
Andre Morris – 1
James Murphy – 1
Derrick Otim – 1
Will Perkins – 1
Adam Spinks – 1
Ugo Uche – 1
Daniel Wright – 1