Roster Analysis: February 2014

Detroit City FC dropped its first real news about the upcoming season yesterday, announcing the return of 15 players from the 2013 squad. Also, although there was never any serious chatter about his status, quotes in yesterday’s announcement confirmed that head coach Ben Pirmann will return for his second season in charge.

Below are a few thoughts on the pre-season roster. Note: I’m solely looking at the players that are currently committed and not taking into account any whose status is uncertain at present. The open spots on the roster will be filled with tryouts on March 22nd and May 3rd.

Forward/Striker

Team MVP and top goalscorer Zach Myers returns and will be the centerpiece of the attack along with fellow starter Wade Allan. The speed of Tom Oatley and the height of Nick Schroeder (6’5”) provide a nice mix of playing styles for Pirmann to mix and match.

Wide Midfield/Wing

DCFC is loaded with talent on the wings with the return of 2013 Great Lakes Conference ‘Best XI’ performers Cyrus Saydee, Jeff Adkins (both First Team), and Miche’le Lipari (Second Team).

Center Midfield

With three players who saw extensive playing time in 2013 – Latif Alashe, Dave Edwardson, Locky Savage – and the return of Spencer Thompson from injury, this position is the deepest on the team.

Fullback

One of the biggest advantages DCFC had over other teams in 2013 was its outstanding fullback play. With both Zach Schewee and Zeke Harris gone, Jonny Evans is the only true player at this position currently on the roster. Left and right back will certainly be at the top of Coach Pirmann’s ‘Needs List’ come tryout time.

Centerback

The heart and soul of the club, Josh Rogers, will return to anchor the back line. With the departures of Adam Bedell, Nick Lewin, and Luke Diener, the search will be on for a new partner for the captain.

Two other returnees, Matt Ybarra and Chase Jabbori, are listed. I have to confess that I haven’t seen enough of them to comment on where they fit in. Detroit City lists them as defenders while their college rosters have them as midfielders. If both do play at the back, that would still only make 4 defenders on the current roster, meaning plenty of opportunities for anyone looking to try out at those positions.

Goalkeeper

This is obviously the most glaring need, since, at the moment, there are no keepers on the roster. Jeremy Clark was brilliant in his two years, and Bret Mollon was so good in 2013 that he essentially became a co-starter. Picking up a good #1 here is crucial, and with the structure of rosters in the NPSL (limited player availability due to family/career/etc.), finding a solid #2 is a must.

[Update: Right after publishing this, Bret Mollon stated that he will be back for 2014.]

Overview

One of my biggest concerns heading into 2013 was that if there was too much roster turnover, the foundation laid by the promising inaugural season would be torn up and the team would have to start from scratch. That concern was mitigated by a large portion of the 2012 team returning, as well as an excellent group of newcomers such as Myers, Mollon, and Kevin Taylor.

By retaining over a dozen contributors, the club has again set itself up for success. The biggest needs are in goal, at both fullback spots, and at centerback opposite Rogers. After that, it would be nice to add a speedy striker who could play a role similar to that of Shawn Lawson in 2013, some depth on the wings, and an attacking midfielder in the Keith Lough/Fabio Pereira mold.

I have no doubt that the popularity and reputation of DCFC is a huge draw to local players, and tryouts will surely become more and more competitive as the status of the club grows.

end

Mirror, Mirror

Sunday, May 12th, 2013 – Detroit City FC 5, FC Sparta 1

invasionofberkley

I’m a big fan of Star Trek. I’ve always been fascinated by its themes of space exploration, the search for intelligent life, and its vision of life in the future. I’m more of a The Next Generation guy, but I appreciate The Original Series and its massive contribution to popular culture. Even if you’re not a Trekkie, you’re probably familiar with the “Goateed Opposite Self from a Parallel Universe” concept.

EVIL
GOOD

———————————————————————————————————————

This comes from an episode in which members of the Enterprise become switched with their evil selves from the Mirror Universe via transporter mishap. Now that I’ve sufficiently bored you I will cut to the chase: I believe FC Sparta Michigan (I think that was their final official name) is Detroit City FC’s polar opposite from a parallel universe.

I’ll discuss my theory in greater detail later, but first I’m going to attempt to recap the brief and bizarre history of the club formerly known colloquially as “The Disease.” My purpose in doing so is to preserve the hilarious ineptitude of this organization for all time. Since Sparta’s web presence and visibility was only slightly higher than Silk Road, I will be basing this section off of memory and pieced-together fragments of social media.

I normally try not to disparage other peoples’ work – I’m far from perfect and I’m sure some would find what I do amateurish and low-rate. I make an exception, however, when it is obvious that the people responsible for a product just don’t give a damn about what they’re doing.

Let this serve as a warning to echo throughout the ages: If you are going to start a 4th division soccer team, try to at least put a little effort into it. If you don’t, people will make fun of you on the Internet.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS

Mid-October 2012

A new NPSL expansion club, Michigan FC Spartans, is announced. The club is an outgrowth of Windsor FC Spartans (aka FC Windsor Spartans), and will play in Berkley, a northern suburb of Detroit.

The club is immediately derided by some supporters of Detroit City FC who see this as an attempt to capitalize on their own club’s success and siphon off part of their fanbase.

A_0p0KLCAAAwuiS

Late 2012-January 2013

Michigan FC Spartans changes its name to FC Sparta Michigan and releases its official crest, featuring a Corinthian helmet with the skyline of Detroit as its backdrop. Some Detroit City supporters find this ironic as FC Sparta does not actually play in the city of Detroit.

fcsparta

Around this time, FC Sparta launches its official Facebook and Twitter accounts. A second official Twitter account is created later and over the course of the next five months, exactly SIX total tweets are sent out.

twitter1twitter2

The official club website is also launched at this time, and it truly deserves a section all its own. The original site no longer exists, but I was able to find a screenshot:

Note the "congradulations"
Note the “congradulations”

Although this is the only shot I was able to track down, it gives a good feel for the general layout and quality of the site as a whole: Web 1.0 (Angelfire/Geocities) format, light text on a black background, misspelled words, terrible grammar, random capitalization and font changes – the list goes on.

[Update 3/30/14: It’s almost two months late, but I just found another shot that I need to include]
No caption necessary
No caption necessary

The site’s content was what made it truly special, though. Some highlights:

  • A rambling statement (in the form of a long block of text with no paragraph breaks) about the club’s philosophy of “Player Development,” said to be based on the Brazilian youth system
  • A page for the team’s bodybuilder strength and conditioning coach, complete with one of his competition photos
  • For a team yet to play a game, not one, not two, but THREE empty pages dedicated to “Accomplishments”

Early 2013

FC Sparta holds a series of player “try outs.” Among those left standing is one Gabriel Poulino, the subject of an AND1-style mixtape entitled: The next Ronaldo: You decide

February 2013

The 2013 NPSL Season Schedule is released. FC Sparta’s first home game is against Detroit City FC.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

“They have way more fans than us. They’re intense. But this is between FC Sparta and Detroit City. We’re going to go and show them what we’ve got. It won’t be a boxing match.”

– FC Sparta Head Coach Eric Kallis

In a previous post, I mentioned that I’ve missed three City home games over the first two seasons. I should have said four because that’s exactly what the “Invasion of Berkley” was: a home game.

977182_657561240925956_191321500_o

Although unable to attend the game, I’ve heard enough first-hand accounts to get a good idea of what it was like. Among the words used in description: surreal…crazy…ridiculous.

919551_657560914259322_1254798150_o

In addition to the local police on patrol watching their every move, everyone entering the stadium was subject to a frisking and/or bag search. We may never know the purpose of the pat-downs (there may have been actual security concerns or they may have been done purely out of spite), but we do know that they were done poorly because a prohibited and potentially dangerous substance made it into the stands undetected:

941649_10201256047231280_1584301587_n

Any worries that Sparta would field a competent team were dispelled in the subsequent 5-1 thumping. With more than a dozen returning players from 2012, and newcomers such as Kevin Taylor and Zach Myers (who scored twice), City was able to get off to a running start and give new head coach Ben Pirmann a win in his first game.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

In every moment of Sparta’s existence, it seemed as though they were trying to do the exact opposite of Detroit City:

  • DCFC chose a simple yet perfect name and stuck with it from day one. Sparta only officially changed names once but were always associated with their Canadian counterparts, so much so that their coach didn’t even bother to wear a jacket with his team’s actual name on it.
    Don't bother going to windsorspartansfc.com - it doesn't exist.
    Don’t bother going to windsorspartansfc.com – it doesn’t exist.
  • DCFC incorporated an iconic city symbol into their crest. Sparta chose to use the image of the RenCen, which, while also iconic, was located 17 miles away from their home field.
  • DCFC teamed up with local independent businesses as sponsors, launched a professional website, and used regular social media updates to spread news about the club. Sparta’s website evoked memories of a time when e-mail was cutting-edge and AOL was America’s hottest company. They also treated social media updates the way a survivor of a zombie apocalypse would treat rounds of ammo – only a few left, save ‘em for when you need ‘em.
  • DCFC immediately attracted multiple supporters’ groups and overall attendance has steadily grown. Sparta’s first home crowd numbered in the tens and never got much larger than that.
  • DCFC’s owners were passionate and committed to their project from the beginning. With everything that went on at Sparta, it was clear that the people in charge were only mildly interested at best.

While these things may not scientifically prove that FC Sparta is from a parallel universe, I think they provide very compelling evidence. If you still doubt my theory, consider this:

971386_517130688352530_2022056393_n

Eric Kallis has a goatee.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

EPLIOGUE

As of today, all that remains of FC Sparta is this teaser on their official website:

lol

As a final testament to their astounding incompetence as an organization, they are promising a new site for a team that no longer exists.

end

State of the Club 2014

[Note: I totally started writing this before the governor’s SOTS address. I will now await his public apology for taking my awesome idea.]

As I’m writing this, it’s the dead of winter and we’re right in the middle of the epoch-long NPSL offseason. In other words, it’s a perfect time to step back and look at the big picture – where we’ve been and where we’re headed.

553330_430410633640478_609788978_n
Cass Tech’s field prior to the inaugural 2012 season.

Two years ago, Detroit City FC was just a name and a crest, still months away from filling its roster and sending those players out on the field. The owners were optimistic enough to hope for an initial crowd of around 500 with numbers hopefully improving with each following game.

Fast forwarding to today, it’s evident that DCFC has been a greater success than anyone could have predicted back in January of 2012. The team has not only been competitive, but has quickly established itself as one of the elite sides in the NPSL, finishing a close 2nd in its division in 2012 and running away with 1st place in 2013 before being upset in the playoffs. Game attendance, including friendlies, has never dipped below the 1000 mark and has swelled to the point that selling out the ~3000 seat Cass Tech H.S. Stadium this season is a very real possibility. On top of that is the passionate, organic support that has drawn considerable attention to the club and has become well-known to many who follow soccer in America.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

Because of this success, more than a few people (supporters as well as outside observers) have raised the possibility of the club moving up to one of US Soccer’s professional divisions – USL PRO, NASL, or MLS. DCFC’s owners have repeatedly stated that the club is essentially a break-even enterprise and that they would not be able to finance a professional side, but let’s just pretend that money is not an issue and speculate for a bit.

MLS:

Despite the best efforts of a number of local groups, it seems doubtful that Detroit will be getting an MLS franchise in the current round of expansion. There is an unrequited love between the MLS-to-Detroit backers and commissioner Don Garber, who to my knowledge has never spoken of Detroit as a serious expansion contender and appears to be looking mainly to Southern markets to award teams #22, 23, and 24. Disregarding all other factors (ownership and financing, stadium, entry fee), the opportunity for DCFC or another Detroit team to join MLS will probably not arise until the next round of expansion, if there is one (2020’s ?).

NASL (2nd Division):

For those hoping to see DCFC play at the professional level at some point in the near future, NASL may be the most realistic option. The league is expanding from 8 to 10 teams this year, adding an additional 3 in 2015, and looking for more.

Former commissioner David Downs (emphasis mine):

In general with expansion, we hope to have 18 to 20 teams by 2018. We’re looking to push farther out west and maybe a couple of cities in the Midwest. There are a number of top-25 markets in the United States that aren’t represented by a professional soccer team.

We believe it’s an obvious marriage to join the N.A.S.L., especially as the price is going up and the number of opportunities getting more and more limited to joining M.L.S. Not every market can afford to support a team at the level of economics of M.L.S. which at the moment is higher than ours.

The current commissioner, Bill Peterson, echoed those statements:

We look at a vision for 2018 with 18-20 teams by then, we see a mix of being in some of the larger metropolitan markets, maybe four to six out of 18 teams, and the rest of the league being in places like Carolina, Indianapolis, or wherever [Ed: mid-level markets]. It’s going to be a mix.

On the downside, joining the NASL would require DCFC to, among other things, secure much larger sources of funding than it currently enjoys, revamp its roster with paid professionals, and find/build a larger stadium with a regulation-sized field. None of these tasks are impossible, but each one is a potential roadblock.

USL PRO (3rd Division):

Due to the murky rules and regulations of lower-division American soccer, I haven’t been able to verify this, but the general consensus of the Detroit area soccer Twitterati is that Michigan Bucks owner Dan Duggan has exclusive rights to put a USL PRO franchise in Southeastern Michigan if he ever chooses to do so. This would exclude DCFC from playing in this division unless Mr. Duggan somehow became the owner of the club through an incredibly bizarre and unfortunate series of events. If this is false, then the same issues with jumping to the NASL would apply here as well. In addition to those, City would run the risk of becoming an MLS farm team thanks to the recently implemented partnership between the two leagues.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

For the time being, the NPSL will remain Detroit City’s home. For all of its drawbacks – different playoff formats across divisions, some clubs paying players while others do not, a “Throw it Against the Wall and See If it Sticks” expansion policy – the league provides excellent opportunities for 2000 players and helps spread the game to under-served areas of the country.

I’ve made my position clear: I’ve found my club and I’ll follow it wherever it goes, whether it remains in the NPSL forever or climbs the ladder up to a professional division. Whatever happens, my foremost concern is that we maintain the enjoyment and sense of belonging we currently experience on gamedays. I’d gladly take a season of 8 home games with a raucous atmosphere over one with 20 or 30 where standing and smokebombs are prohibited.

As the reputation and fanbase of DCFC continues to grow, it may eventually attract larger sponsors and investment. At that point, the most important issue will become the balancing of necessary business (marketing, prices, salaries, etc.) with what made the club a success in the first place: the name/crest/colors, the play on the field, the stadium atmosphere, and the feeling of community.

end

Summer Camp

Wednesday, July 18th, 2012 – Detroit City FC 0, Windsor Stars 0

Via DCFC Facebook
Via DCFC Facebook

I never spent a summer at camp, but I’ve seen enough movies to get the general idea.

R-7411648-1440955293-5219.jpeg

———————————-

My following of Detroit City’s first season took on the same basic story arc:

Part 1 – Slight apprehension, not knowing what to expect

Part 2 – Getting used to the people and surroundings

Part 3 – Defining moments, both high and low

Part 4 – Realizing you really like it here and hating when you have to leave

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

The friendly against Windsor was unremarkable in terms of on-field play – a scoreless draw with a few excellent saves by both goalkeepers – but the post-game scene was unforgettable to those who were there.

This end-of-the-season celebration – fans, players, coaches, owners, and media jumping around and singing together – is a microcosm for why many of us care so deeply about a 4th divison soccer club. We care because this is such an exciting, unique experience. We care because the people in the organization are genuine and work their asses off. We care because it’s really, really fun.

In the age of the San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl and the KFC Yum! Center (Yes, that is the actual name of a sports arena. Click the link if you don’t believe me), we have an outlet for escaping this accumulation of corporate gunk (for the most part) and experiencing a sport for what it was meant to be: an enjoyable, entertaining way to spend your free time.

We may not have buckets of money and a shiny, state-of-the-art camp like the rich kids across the lake, but we have something that they don’t – the opportunity to build a club and a culture from the ground up, the way we want it.

616175_500492079966207_534535866_o

As the field cleared for the last time that summer, I did what many of us do at the end of a great vacation or a summer at camp. I started counting the days ‘til I could come back.

end

Graduation Day

Sunday, July 1st, 2012 – Detroit City FC 1, Erie 2

170397_491971524151596_381787254_o

Another title that I’ve shamelessly borrowed from Fever Pitch, “Graduation Day” is a chapter in which Nick Hornby describes his “debut” as a fifteen year old – moving from the Schoolboys’ Enclosure to the North Bank, the Arsenal supporters’ section at Highbury.

I had plotted my debut with great care. For much of that season I’d spent more time staring at the alarming lump of noisy humanity to my right than straight ahead at the pitch; I was trying to work out exactly where I would make for and what parts I should avoid.

The final regular season game of 2012, in which the division winner would be decided, was my graduation day. Up to then, I’d watched every game from the main stand, frequently referred to as the “Family Stand” or “The Quiet Side.” If asked to describe myself, the words loud, rowdy, and boisterous would never be used, but I couldn’t keep myself away from the supporters’ section any longer – it just looked too damn fun.

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

As with the Rust Belt Derby showdown with Cleveland, this game didn’t go according to plan. In the scorching heat of a Sunday afternoon an early City own goal and a late winner gave Erie the 2-1 victory and the division title. In the first round of the divisional playoffs two weeks later, Cleveland ended City’s season by the same score.

Despite the season ending with a whimper, my experience in the supporters’ section was invigorating. Contrary to some reports and complaints, I found that the people around me were not murders, arsonists, rapists, or human traffickers. Some of them are mentally unstable, but having too many normal people in one place would be boring anyway.

Bk5t6OsCYAA8nD8
I’m going to post the hell out of this forever.

I’m an easygoing guy, but I also believe that there is no better reliever of stress than screaming and yelling at the top of your lungs. Most of us have ample daily motivation to do this, but because of our fears of firing, arrest, and general alienation of the people around us, our opportunities are frustratingly few and far between. Unless you regularly find yourself on the top of a mountain or the bow of a ship, sporting events are pretty much all you’ve got.

A raucous atmosphere is the exception and not the rule in pro sports. College football and basketball are better, but generally favor raw noise instead of coordination. Soccer is easily the best outlet for vocal energies and visual displays.

[ ^ Number 2 on my 2014 song/chant wishlist behind Dirty Old Town.]

– – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –

I love the supporters’ section and that’s where I’ll be for the forseeable future, but there is something to be said for sitting across the field in the main stand. Watching a soccer game is nice, but watching a soccer game with a mass of people in the background and a wall of sound coming at you is incredible.

Again from Fever Pitch:

…atmosphere is one of the crucial ingredients of the football experience. These huge ends [supporter sections] are as vital to the clubs as their players, not only because their inhabitants are vocal in their support, not just because they provide clubs with large sums of money, but because without them nobody else would bother coming.

It would be arrogant and presumptuous for supporters to claim credit for all of DCFC’s success – the players, coaches, and owners (most of whom have careers outside of the club) have put in thousands of hours of their time and thousands of dollars of their own money into a situation where success is essentially measured by entertaining people and breaking even.

That being said, supporters ARE responsible for the club’s popularity. Without a passionate, dedicated, vocal following, Detroit City would simply be at best another run-of-the-mill team with a few hundred people showing up to each game, or at worst another occupant of the ever-growing NPSL expansion graveyard (52 and counting since the league’s inception in 2003).

Having sat in the main stand and listened to the people around me, I can say that a great number of them were there not only because of the winning team on the field, but also because of the incredible atmosphere that is generated. As a wise man once said, “We make the party and people show up.”

1017493_672962686052478_1839064390_n

end